Reproductive Choice - Viagra vs. the Birth-Control Pill in Japan
Mar 1999
Family Planning: Viagra vs. the Birth-Control Pill in Japan
Search for:



Home

"In the three decades it has deliberated over the pill, the Health Ministry has raised a number of health concerns. Initially, it raised worries about side effects from the pill's high level of hormones. The ministry now cites worries about sexually transmitted diseases, cancer, and environmental damage from hormone residue in the urine of women using the pill" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"Though the ministry accepted data from US clinical tests about Viagra, it is not swayed by Japanese tests on the pill or its overseas approval. 'There are still things that need to be debated,' explains spokesman Yasuhide Furusawa" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"Family-planning groups and some doctors see chauvinism in the delay, saying it reflects a male-dominated society's desire to limit women's choices. But two factors shape the struggle over the pill even more deeply" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"The first is Japan's declining birthrate, a matter of intense political concern because of its enormous economic and social impact. Senior politicians from the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) have expressed concern that the pill would further depress the birthrate" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"Second, the government has generally used its regulatory power to manage population size. 'Basically, government attitudes and male parliamentarians attitudes haven't changed at all,' says Yuriko Ashino of the Family Planning Federation of Japan. 'Their basic thinking is against women's reproductive rights. That idea is deeply rooted'"(Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"When Japan modernized in the late 1800s, it passed laws banning abortion and infanticide, because Western economic models favored large industrial work forces. When depression struck after World War I, the government began promoting family planning" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"The tide shifted in the lead-up to World War II, when the government used the slogan 'Bear Children. Swell the Population'" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"Defeat brought a lack of food and housing, a baby boom, the repatriation of thousands of Japanese from former colonies, and revived interest in birth control. The government's 19th-century ban on abortion still stood, so it passed a law permitting abortions for medical, eugenic, ethical, or economic reasons" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"Unless an abortion falls under one of the exceptions, technically it is punishable under criminal law. In the 1980's, when concern about the declining birthrate was growing rapidly, the LDP tried but failed to strip the economic justification for abortions from the law. This clause covers 90 percent of abortions, which are a large lucrative industry here. Unwanted pregnancies - 36 percent in Japan - compared with 19 percent in the US in 1992" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"With more women in government campaigning for the pill's approval, that may soon change. Some politicians, like Democratic Party's Yoko Komiyama, expect to see a difference within the next year. But she tells a story that illustrates the Health Ministry's tight-lipped approach - even with legislators" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"When Ms. Komiyama asked the health minister last month how meetins on the pill were progressing, he told her that it was important to protect the free speech of decisionmakers. With that in mind, he said, it might be possible to release minutes of their meetings in two years" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).

"'The committee [deliberating on the pill] is very closed,' Ms. Komiyama observes, 'and mostly male'" (Nicole Gaouette, The Christian Science Monitor, March 11, 1999).


Comments? Questions? Write me at george@loper.org.